I do understand exactly your strategy. And here is my dos pesos.
Have you taken a look at the wiki ? It's at
www.quantnet.com/wiki
Take away the top programs in NYC, you are left with quite a few in NY/NJ area.
Your best best would be with relatively new programs such as Fordham, New School or those without a strong location advantage/local reputation/pull such as Polytech, Stevens, Rutgers. On the national scale, you may want to look at IIT and bunches of other program in midwest, central US.
You can even apply to Columbia MF/MFE program. From what I read, if you don't get in, they would gladly "
recommend" you to some of their
other programs. Very convenient.
Those are just names that ought to meet your criteria. A more defined list would be filtered down by you or by people with knowledge of your background, strength, weakness and career goal.